HIST 1101: Minnesota History

Professor Janke
Summer 2024

 

 Field Trip Paper Assignment #2

20% of your final course grade

 

 Virtual Field Trip #2: The State Capitol and the Artwork -- You CANNOT write this virtual option if you have written a paper about an in-person visit to the Capitol.  (The Capitol building is currently open and available as an in-person IRL field trip, so if you have the time to visit St. Paul, I would recommend that!)

 

This assignment involves taking a “virtual tour” of the state Capitol and then you will consider some issues related to this site, drawing on what you have learned from the course readings.  To repeat: in order to write a strong paper, you must draw on what you’ve learned in the course, and this will likely include going back to re-read or review past assignments.  The best way to demonstrate that you’ve made connections between the field trip location and course materials is to include quotations and examples from the class readings.

 


Due
 Friday, 8/2 at NOON (last day of the class).  Any papers turned in after NOON will be counted as one day late.  Late papers accrue a penalty of 3 points per day.   Submit to the Assignment Dropbox.  Note that there is very little wiggle room at the end of the class to accept a late paper.

Extra credit points available!  If you meet with a writing tutor (more information will be posted on D2L) you can earn 5 extra credit points added to your paper score.

In this paper your job is to consider what you’ve learned about the history of our state, Minnesota’s “founding fathers,” and Minnesota’s indigenous peoples, and use that knowledge to analyze a recent debate about artwork that was on display at the Capitol.

Step One: 

Visit the Capitol’s website and take a “virtual tour,” clicking through to learn as much about the building and its history as you can.  Make sure to include these two links and make sure the watch the video that’s part of the “Reconciling History” link.

https://www.mnhs.org/capitol/learn

https://www.mnhs.org/capitol/learn/art/reconciling-history

Step Two:

Review what you have learned in this course and think about which readings connect to this topic as a whole.   Figuring out which course readings to use when writing your paper is part of the challenge of the assignment so I will not be giving many specific hints or suggestions.  My advice would be to look over the course schedule and the North Country note-taking guide to refresh your memory of the topics we have covered.  For example, we read quite a bit about the topic of the Treaty of Traverse des Sioux and also Father Hennepin – the topics that are depicted in two artworks that are part of this debate.  Also note: the reading from North Country assigned for the last week of class mentions this topic towards the very end.  Check it out! (North Country, Epilogue, p. 346-60.)

Take another look at the notetaking guide for North Country as that has identified some possible locations of course materials.  There may be others that you noticed, but this is a good place to start.

 

Step Three:

Write a 3 page double-spaced paper considering these questions:

 As you will learn, during a recent renovation there was much discussion about the artwork that was on display.  What are some of the issues regarding the displays of artwork?  Based on what you learned from course materials, what do you think about displaying the paintings?  What do you think is the best way to resolve this issue?  Do you agree with the decision the Capitol made?  Why or why not?  And if not, what other solution would you propose instead?  Since the State Capitol building should ideally symbolize and represent all Minnesotans, why do you think choices related to artwork and other displays are both important and controversial?  Do you think the Capitol's website does a good job teaching about Minnesota history?

While this paper asks you to give your opinion about this, your opinion should be informed by what you’ve learned in this course and I will expect to see some explicit references (quotes) from course materials to support your point of view.  I am also expecting to see a clear thesis statement, ideally at the end of the first paragraph.  If you're unsure of whether you have a good thesis statement, feel free to share it with Linda and/or a writing tutor.  Having a strong thesis statement helps build a strong paper! 

 

 

Writing, Formatting and Citations:

You must turn in at least three double-spaced typed pages, with reasonable margins and font sizes, i.e. no font larger than 12 point, no extra spaces between paragraphs, and no margins larger than one inch.  I will reformat papers which do not meet these criteria.  I will be happy to read papers longer than three pages; papers less than three pages will be penalized.   This is a formal academic paper so I expect you to use proper paragraph development, grammar, spelling, punctuation, etc.  Your paper grade will be based, in part, on your writing as well as the content within the paper. 

You must save your papers in a format that I can open.  Be sure to check your e-mail on the day papers are due because if I cannot open your paper for some reason I will be in touch with you directly.  I prefer papers saved in Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx) but I can also open PDFs.  I cannot open files saved in "Open Office."  Do not share a Google Doc.

Most, if not all, of your paper should be in your own words. Be very careful not to accidentally copy something from course materials or the websites you used for research -- copying even phrases or parts of a sentence can be considered plagiarism. 

Citations:  Much like your quiz answers, you must demonstrate to me that you acquired your information for this paper from your field trip location website and course materials.  Do NOT do outside research or ask ChatGPT.  At the end of each paragraph, tell me where you found the information.  This does not need to be a formal citation -- just a way to let me know where you got your information.  I think the easiest way to accomplish this would be to name the title of the webpage and then the paragraph where you found the information.  That sort of thing!  When you are using course materials to analyze your visit (a required part of the paper) you can cite the name of the material and a page number, such as [North Country, 32.]  If you use a direct quotation (very strongly recommended!) you must tell me the page number for the quotation.  I am expecting that the end of each paragraph could have several different sources listed.  That's fine!  I don't care about the specific formatting of citations, just that you demonstrate you acquired the information from the assigned websites and course materials. 

In short, I won’t worry too much about the format of the citations just that you have them at the end of each paragraph, and that the paper is in your own words or properly quoted/cited.

 

A Word About Plagiarism:

 

I cannot stress this point enough: Copying ANY PORTION of your paper directly from internet sources, the course textbooks, AND/OR from classmates will result in failing the paper.  Again, copying ANYTHING, including short phrases, from other sources or a classmate will result in a grade of ZERO on the paper.  In other words, this paper must be written ENTIRELY (100%) IN YOUR OWN WORDS.  This paper is designed to describe and analyze YOUR experience. Using AI or Chat GPT is not permitted and will be considered academic dishonesty.